Lately I’ve been seeing a lot of TV ads touting how a “gift” of heating oil from “the People of Venezuela” is helping poor people in the US. The deal was brokered by Massachusetts’ Rep. Bill Delahunt and former representative Joe Kennedy, and is administered by Citgo. Sounds limke a win-win all round.
Well, not quite all around.
The official Venezuelan government figures claim that poverty had been reduced from 60% to under 40%- still extremely high- while independant observers claim the actual numbers range from 60% to over 80%. And the poverty live in Venezuela is far lower than in the US. The average per-capita consumption in Venezuela is only $6700, and that includes all societal strata.
What it comes down to is that Venezuela is, by the standards of Western democracies, a dirt-poor country- but for some reason they’re subsidizing people in the US whose standard of living is many times higher. And they’re doing it by, in essence, giving away a commodity that is responsible for 30% of the nation’s GDP. It’s sort of like me and my neighbors getting together and donating money to the Kennedys, or to Bill Gates. (Scratch that second one. I think we already do that.)
(And speaking of the Kennedys- Joe Kennedy gets a $400,000/year salary from the Citizens Energy Corporation, who put the deal together.)
I’m picturing a family in rural Venezuela living in a one-room house, living by subsistence farming, sitting around eating the daily meal. Dad takes a bite of the evening’s potato stew, and says, “You know, we have it pretty good here. We’ve got a roof, a garden, and there’s a doctor only 50 miles away. But I’ve heard that in Massachusetts there are people who have an income of less than $24,000. Some of them don’t even have cable TV. What say we tighten our belts and maybe send them some oil? And maybe we can throw in a few bucks for Joe Kennedy, too.”